• العربية
  • فارسی
BrandBrand
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
  • Theme
  • Language
    • العربية
    • فارسی
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
All rights reserved for Volant Media UK Limited
volant media logo

Pence says US halted Iran war too soon, disputes Vance on midterm losses

Nov 15, 2026, 16:47 GMT+0

Former US Vice President Mike Pence said Sunday that Washington's decision to halt its military campaign against Iran contributed to Republican midterm losses, rejecting Vice President JD Vance's argument that the war itself had cost the party votes.

"Vice President Vance is wrong," Pence said on NBC's Meet the Press, arguing that the US military had achieved major successes during Operation Epic Fury before the administration abruptly stopped the campaign after five weeks. He cited the destruction of Iran's navy, American air superiority and strikes on 15,000 military sites.

Pence accused the Trump administration of embracing the "politics of appeasement" after suspending the attacks. He pointed to reported Iranian strikes against US targets in Bahrain over the past 24 hours as evidence that Tehran did not consider itself defeated, despite the damage inflicted by American forces.

"There's an old saying that you don't make peace with your enemy, you make peace with your defeated enemy,” he said.

Vance said Americans were frustrated by rising gasoline and diesel prices and Washington's failure to finish the military campaign, rather than the initial decision to attack Iran. Pence suggested that growing isolationist influence within the Republican Party had contributed to the administration's decision to halt the offensive.

Most Viewed

Iran's oil output plunges below pre-war domestic needs
1
ANALYSIS

Iran's oil output plunges below pre-war domestic needs

2

Iran state TV says modified missile could reach US base in Britain

3

Cash-strapped Iranians put multiple organs up for sale

4
ONE-ON-ONE

Iranians and Israelis can defeat the IRGC together, says Arab-Israeli activist

5

Seven years after ‘Bloody November,’ Iran rations gasoline it dares not reprice

Banner

Spotlight

  • Can higher fuel prices curb Iran’s smuggling problem?
    ANALYSIS

    Can higher fuel prices curb Iran’s smuggling problem?

  • Canadian MP to flag paintball gun findings after Iran protest blindings
    PODCAST

    Canadian MP to flag paintball gun findings after Iran protest blindings

  • Locks for cash: inside Iran's booming hair trade

    Locks for cash: inside Iran's booming hair trade

  • Seven years after ‘Bloody November,’ Iran rations gasoline it dares not reprice

    Seven years after ‘Bloody November,’ Iran rations gasoline it dares not reprice

  • Iranians and Israelis can defeat the IRGC together, says Arab-Israeli activist
    ONE-ON-ONE

    Iranians and Israelis can defeat the IRGC together, says Arab-Israeli activist

  • Iran's oil output plunges below pre-war domestic needs
    ANALYSIS

    Iran's oil output plunges below pre-war domestic needs

Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
•
•
•

More Stories

Blair's sister-in-law attended Iran conference linked to IRGC spy recruitment - Telegraph

Nov 15, 2026, 16:27 GMT+0
100%

Former British Prime Minister Tony Blair's sister-in-law attended a conference in Iran that US authorities later identified as a platform for intelligence recruitment by the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), The Telegraph reported on Sunday.

Lauren Booth, the half-sister of Blair's wife Cherie, was a guest speaker at the New Horizon conference in Mashhad in 2018, a year before Washington sanctioned its organizers over alleged intelligence-gathering activities.

The Telegraph identified several British activists who had attended conferences organized by New Horizon, an Iranian organization that US authorities say helped the IRGC's Quds Force recruit foreign nationals and collect intelligence.

The newspaper stressed that there was no suggestion Booth or the other British attendees had been recruited as spies or worked with Iranian intelligence.

US sanctioned conference organizers over intelligence recruitment

The US Treasury sanctioned the New Horizon Organization and four associated individuals in February 2019, saying its international conferences had provided Iranian intelligence officers opportunities to recruit attendees.

The Treasury said the events served "as a platform for the IRGC-QF to recruit and collect intelligence from attendees."

It also said organizers had facilitated contact between the Revolutionary Guards and American citizens, while promoting antisemitism and Holocaust denial.

Among those sanctioned was Nader Talebzadeh, the organization's chairman and a prominent Iranian filmmaker who helped organize the conferences.

The events were also linked to the recruitment of Monica Witt, a former US Air Force counterintelligence specialist who defected to Iran in 2013 after attending New Horizon conferences.

US prosecutors subsequently charged Witt with espionage-related offenses, alleging that she disclosed classified information and assisted Iranian intelligence operations.

A 2025 report by Britain's parliamentary Intelligence and Security Committee concluded that the IRGC had almost certainly used New Horizon conferences to gain access to and recruit foreign nationals.

100%

British activists attended Iranian conferences

The Telegraph reported that Booth was among several British figures who participated in New Horizon events.

Others included former Church of England vicar Stephen Sizer, who attended a conference in 2014, and Rabbi Ahron Cohen, a member of the anti-Zionist Neturei Karta movement, who attended in 2012.

In a 2018 blog post, Booth described the Mashhad gathering as a "rare opportunity" for journalists, former diplomats, politicians and activists to discuss geopolitical issues.

The newspaper also examined connections between conference attendees and Abrar House, a charity-owned building in London's Marylebone district that has hosted talks by several of the individuals.

Roger Macmillan, a former security director at Iran International, told The Telegraph that Western figures promoting Tehran's positions were a "gift horse" to the Islamic Republic because they could repeat the government's messaging to foreign audiences.

100%

Jonathan Hackett, a former US intelligence agent, said Iran sought Western voices who could influence audiences more effectively than Iranian officials.

"These people can be completely unwitting and can still be just as useful to the regime," he said.

Booth rejects criticism as UK charity regulator examines concerns

Booth rejected criticism of her participation and accused The Telegraph of promoting Israeli government narratives.

She called the newspaper a "mindless mouthpiece" for Israel, challenging its characterization of Western conference attendees as unwitting promoters of Iranian propaganda.

The Abrar Islamic Foundation, which owns Abrar House, rejected suggestions that it had provided a platform for antisemitism or extremism.

It said it had no connection to the New Horizon conferences and that Booth and Cohen had spoken at events organized by third parties.

The foundation also stressed that the individuals had attended New Horizon conferences before the organization was sanctioned by Washington.

Britain's Charity Commission confirmed that it had an active regulatory compliance case involving the foundation and was examining additional information to determine whether further concerns had arisen.

The Telegraph reported that the commission had received a dossier concerning speakers and events hosted at Abrar House.

The regulator has not announced findings of wrongdoing in connection with the latest information.

Bus carrying gas refinery workers overturns in western Iran, killing 12

Nov 15, 2026, 15:23 GMT+0
100%

At least 12 workers from a major Iranian gas processing project were killed when their bus overturned in western Iran, as authorities launched an investigation into the cause of the deadly crash.

The bus, carrying 27 workers and a driver from the Dehloran gas processing project, overturned on Saturday evening on a road between Dasht-e Abbas and Murmuri in Ilam province, near Iran's border with Iraq.

Behzad Nourmohammadi, governor of Abdanan county, told the state-run IRNA news agency that three passengers died after being transferred to medical facilities, bringing the death toll to 12.

He warned that the toll could rise because several injured passengers remained in critical condition.

Sixteen people were hospitalized, including 10 in Dezful, five in Abdanan and one in Ilam.

Investigation launched into cause of crash

Abdanan prosecutor Amrollah Misai said investigators were examining the cause of the crash and whether negligence by individuals or responsible government agencies had contributed to the accident.

The bus was transporting personnel working on the Dehloran NGL 3100 project, a natural gas liquids processing facility in southern Ilam province.

100%

The cause of the crash has not yet been established. Iranian media quoted a driver familiar with the route as saying the bend where the bus overturned had a history of accidents.

Crash highlights Iran's road safety crisis

The accident comes amid persistently high traffic fatalities in Iran, where more than 19,000 people have died in road crashes annually for four consecutive years.

According to figures from Iran's Forensic Medicine Organization cited by the ILNA news agency, 10,357 people died in traffic accidents during the first six months of the current Iranian calendar year, which began in March.

Of those killed, 1,868 were between the ages of 18 and 24.

Iranian police officials have repeatedly raised concerns about vehicle safety and hazardous roads, calling for improvements in manufacturing standards, road infrastructure and enforcement.

The country's industry minister, Mohammad Atabak, recently requested a delay of at least one year in implementing new vehicle safety standards, citing currency shortages, emergency conditions and automakers' financial constraints.

Israeli opposition to Islamic Republic transcends party lines

Nov 15, 2026, 14:44 GMT+0
•
Kambiz Tavana
100%
Former military chief Gadi Eisenkot, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, heads of parties and other Israeli officials gather for a family photo on the day of the inauguration of Israel's 26th parliament, at the Knesset in Jerusalem, November 10, 2026.

Opposition to the Islamic Republic will remain a point of consensus in Israel regardless of who forms its next government, according to Israeli-American journalist and Iran analyst Emily Schrader.

"It's not a partisan issue in Israel," she told Iran International's Kambiz Tavana. "No one in the mainstream, from left to right, wants the Islamic Republic to continue."

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's bloc won 53 of the Knesset's 120 seats in last month's election. Although opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot's Yashar party won fewer seats than Netanyahu's Likud, Eisenkot emerged with broader parliamentary support and was tasked by President Isaac Herzog with forming a government.

Schrader said the outcome reflected domestic grievances rather than Netanyahu's record against Iran and its allies.

"Netanyahu internationally and Netanyahu domestically are very, very different equations," she said, adding that most Israelis respect how he handled the war with Iran and the fight against Hezbollah, including the pager operation.

She pointed instead to anger over the hostage negotiations, Netanyahu's corruption trial and the absence of a state commission of inquiry into the failures of Oct. 7.

Asked whether an Eisenkot government would be softer on Tehran, she said representatives of Yashar had told her they support regime change.

"If there is a unity government that would see Eisenkot and Netanyahu together, most likely we're not going to see a lot of policy changes," she said. "Probably a very similar approach to Iran, which I think will be the case anyway."

The bigger domestic change, she said, could come over the drafting of ultra-Orthodox men into the army, one of the main election issues.

100%
Emily Schrader, an Israeli-American journalist and Iran analyst, speaks in an interview with Iran International's Kambiz Tavana in Washington DC on Nov. 13, 2026

'That's how desperate they are'

Schrader said the world had failed to grasp the desperation of Iranians living under the Islamic Republic.

"The Iranian public is in such a state of crisis, in such a state of desperation, that there were people who wanted their country to be bombed," she said. "Not their country, but the IRGC and the regime. But that's how desperate they are."

She criticized the UN General Assembly's Nov. 11 vote to elect Iran to its Committee for Programme and Coordination, with 144 votes, for a three-year term starting in January.

The vote came, she said, "after they massacred at least 40,000 of their own people in the streets in two days."

"Why is this not being spoken about? On what planet is that a normal thing to do?" she said, adding that the Islamic Republic was now significantly weaker, creating an opening for Iranians even if it survived.

US President Donald Trump told radio host Hugh Hewitt on Nov. 12 that it "would be a defeat" if Iran's rulers were still in power when he leaves office. Schrader said she was "cautiously optimistic" about relief for Iranians.

She said both the Trump administration and Netanyahu's government now felt pressure to deal with Iran following their respective elections, pointing to Trump's remarks to reporters the day after the US midterms, when he was asked whether Republicans had lost because of the Iran war.

Speaking to reporters on Nov. 4, after Democrats won control of both chambers of Congress, Trump said it was "largely true" that the war had hurt Republicans because it "drove the gasoline up a little bit," but added that "if I had to do it again, I'd have to do it again," Newsweek reported.

Accounts posing abroad

Schrader also addressed a recent online dispute with Persian-language accounts that accused her of working against Netanyahu during the Israeli election campaign.

She alleged that some accounts presenting themselves as users in Germany and Britain were actually operating from inside Iran during the internet shutdown.

"There were some things that were true mixed in with things that weren't true, which is a very classic tactic that we've seen from the IRGC," she said.

She acknowledged she had explained the debate over monarchy and democracy poorly, but said the two were "not mutually exclusive."

"When it comes to Iran, it's not up to me. It's up to the Iranian people," she said.

"It really breaks my heart to see how the Iranian people are crying out for help," Schrader said. "There are teenagers willing to die to free their country, for the hope of freeing their country."

Toxic air chokes Iranian cities, residents report health problems

Nov 15, 2026, 12:41 GMT+0
•
Baharan Azadi
100%
File photo: Tehran’s skyline shrouded in thick smog, with Milad Tower barely visible through the polluted air.

Worsening air pollution across Iran has left citizens reporting headaches, nausea and breathing difficulties, with many criticizing authorities for keeping schools open, according to accounts received by Iran International.

People in Isfahan, Tehran, Mashhad, Urmia, Arak, Karaj and Kermanshah described worsening air quality and its effects on public health, particularly among elderly people and those with underlying medical conditions.

"Fuel oil burning and air pollution have become so severe in Isfahan that most of our family suffers from headaches much of the time," a citizen wrote.

Another person in Urmia described persistent headaches affecting family members.

"Our city has become extremely polluted, and we have headaches every day. We take painkillers, but they don't help," the resident said.

"The city smells like burning tires. We can barely breathe in this air, and it hasn't even turned cold yet. Imagine what winter will be like," a Mashhad resident said.

Tehran residents report breathing difficulties

Tehran's air quality index reached 153 on Friday evening, November 13, a level considered unhealthy for all groups.

By Sunday morning, November 15, the index stood at 125, indicating conditions unhealthy for sensitive groups.

Citizens reported reduced visibility, burning eyes, headaches and respiratory problems.

  • Tehran faces worsening smog as officials issue new health warning

    Tehran faces worsening smog as officials issue new health warning

"Tehran has become like Chernobyl," one person said in a video sent to Iran International.

Another compared the pollution to Nazi gas chambers, accusing authorities of gradually killing people through exposure to polluted air.

A Tehran resident described a sudden deterioration in air quality over several days and accused authorities of contributing to the pollution.

Another reported overcrowding at Tehran's Milad Hospital, saying many patients were seeking treatment for shortness of breath and severe coughing.

"Which problem are we supposed to endure? Inflation, petrol shortages or being unable to breathe?" another citizen asked, describing severe headaches and nausea.

Anger over schools remaining open

Parents and students also criticized authorities for keeping schools open despite worsening air quality.

A Tehran student reported coughing and experiencing breathing difficulties while returning home from school.

A person in Shahr-e Qods, west of Tehran, criticized the continuation of classes despite severe pollution and reduced visibility.

"These officials don't care about people in the slightest," the resident wrote.

"Are you aware of Tehran's pollution, or are you asleep? We can't breathe. Why aren't you closing schools?" another citizen asked.

Fuel oil burning continues

The complaints come alongside official confirmation that mazut, a heavy fuel oil, continues to be used in industrial facilities and power plants because of natural gas shortages.

Gas supplies to cement factories have been cut, forcing producers to switch to mazut, a situation likely to continue until March, Ali-Akbar Alvandian, secretary of the Cement Industry Employers Association, said on November 3.

  • Students shiver in classrooms as Iran government warns of gas cuts

    Students shiver in classrooms as Iran government warns of gas cuts

A citizen in Pardis, near Tehran, previously reported severe pollution and white smoke covering the western part of the city, attributing the conditions to a nearby cement factory burning mazut.

Securing sufficient fuel for power plants will become more difficult during winter, and mazut will continue to be used as an alternative, Mostafa Rajabi Mashhadi, deputy energy minister for electricity, confirmed on November 14.

People had also raised concerns about mazut burning during the summer.

  • Air pollution claimed 6,000 lives in Tehran over the past year, officials say

    Air pollution claimed 6,000 lives in Tehran over the past year, officials say

A Karaj resident reported sharply reduced visibility and worsening pollution, linking the conditions to fuel oil use at power plants.

Another person in Kermanshah said the Bisotun power plant had burned mazut in two generating units for more than two months, producing substantial pollution.

2019 crackdown failed to break cycle of Iran street protests

Nov 15, 2026, 11:45 GMT+0
•
Ata Mohamed Tabriz
100%
People protest against increased gas price, on a highway in Tehran, Iran November 16, 2019.

Iran's deadly crackdown on protests in November 2019 failed to prevent successive uprisings, fueling a cycle of unrest driven by economic hardship, restrictions on personal freedoms and increasingly forceful repression.

The November 2019 protests marked a turning point in Iran's political landscape, widening the divide between the Islamic Republic and much of society.

Authorities sought to deter further demonstrations through mass arrests, lethal force and nationwide internet shutdowns. But the grievances that brought people into the streets persisted, and new sources of discontent accumulated.

  • Grieving Mothers Speak Out On Anniversary Of Iran’s Bloody November

    Grieving Mothers Speak Out On Anniversary Of Iran’s Bloody November

The cycle continued through protests in 2021, the Woman, Life, Freedom uprising in 2022 and another nationwide wave in January 2026, which began over economic hardship and faced the deadliest crackdown in recent decades.

November 2019: From fuel prices to mass killings

The November 2019 protests erupted against a backdrop of rising inflation, regional inequality and growing poverty on the outskirts of major cities.

On November 15, authorities announced overnight increases of 200 percent in the price of unsubsidized gasoline and 50 percent for subsidized fuel, without prior public notice.

The decision triggered demonstrations that rapidly expanded beyond opposition to fuel prices into a broader rejection of the political system and Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei.

Within 48 to 72 hours, protests had spread to between 100 and 200 cities across 22 to 28 provinces, with major centers in Khuzestan, the outskirts of Tehran, Alborz and several western and central provinces.

Many participants came from what sociologists describe as the impoverished middle class: residents of smaller cities and urban peripheries whose expectations resembled those of the middle class but whose economic circumstances were closer to those of lower-income groups.

The demonstrations lacked established organizations and coordinated leadership, contributing to their rapid, decentralized spread.

The rejection of Iran's political establishment had already emerged during protests in December 2017 and January 2018, when demonstrators chanted that both reformists and conservatives had exhausted their political relevance.

  • Anatomy of a massacre, and the mothers who refuse to let November end

    Anatomy of a massacre, and the mothers who refuse to let November end

By November 2019, opposition to the Islamic Republic itself was evident from the beginning.

The government, backed by reformist political forces, implemented the fuel price increase and internet shutdown before distancing itself from responsibility for the consequences.

Officials described protesters as "thugs" and characterized the demonstrations as "urban warfare," presenting the crackdown as necessary to protect national security and public order.

Authorities imposed a nationwide shutdown of international internet access under a decision by the country's security council.

Special police units, the Revolutionary Guards and the Basij militia deployed alongside armed personnel using live ammunition. Between 7,000 and 8,600 people were arrested.

In Mahshahr, southern Iran, security forces fired bursts from heavy weapons at protesters and residents who had sought refuge in nearby marshlands.

Reuters subsequently reported, citing sources familiar with the decision-making, that Khamenei had ordered the protests stopped at any cost.

The scale of the killings became a central source of public anger, compounded by the absence of accountability for those responsible.

"Well, shots were fired at their legs too," then-Interior Minister Abdolreza Rahmani Fazli said when questioned about why protesters had been shot in the head, according to former lawmaker Mahmoud Sadeghi.

The remarks did not lead to the prosecution of officials who ordered the crackdown. An effort to impeach Rahmani Fazli also failed to advance in parliament.

Mojtaba Zolnouri, then head of parliament's national security committee, defended the minister's actions as implementation of presidential orders and decisions by the country's security authorities.

Estimates of the death toll varied widely. Then-Interior Minister Abdolreza Rahmani Fazli put the figure at between 200 and 225, while Amnesty International documented hundreds of deaths. Reuters, citing Iranian Interior Ministry officials, reported that approximately 1,500 people had been killed.

The wide differences between official and independent estimates of the death toll, coupled with the lack of accountability, helped sustain demands for justice long after the protests had subsided.

How the memory of 2019 shaped the 2022 uprising

The legacy of November 2019 extended beyond the immediate political consequences of the crackdown.

Cultural sociologist Jeffrey Alexander argues that suffering can become a collective trauma when a wider community identifies with the victims through a shared narrative of their suffering and those responsible.

Families seeking justice for those killed in November 2019 helped construct such a narrative.

Annual commemorations, repeated publication of victims' names and accounts shared by grieving mothers on social media transformed the losses of hundreds of families into a wider public concern.

The protest slogan "Aban continues," referring to the Iranian calendar month in which the killings occurred, captured the persistence of that memory.

The anniversary of the crackdown helped determine the timing of protest calls in November 2022, during the Woman, Life, Freedom uprising.

Families of those killed in 2019 also provided a model for relatives seeking accountability after subsequent crackdowns.

In April 2025, Kamelia Sajadian, whose son Mohammad Hassan Torkaman was killed during the 2022 protests, launched the "I too am someone's mother" campaign.

The initiative drew on words associated with Pouya Bakhtiari, killed in November 2019, and subsequently repeated by his mother, Nahid Shirpisheh. Mothers of victims from both the 2019 and 2022 protests joined the campaign.

But the persistence of protest cannot be explained by collective memory alone.

Economic conditions that helped fuel the 2019 demonstrations deteriorated over the following three years.

Persistent inflation, the declining value of the national currency and shrinking household purchasing power pushed more middle-class Iranians toward poverty and deepened hardship among those already struggling.

The Islamic Republic also consolidated political power following the 2021 presidential election, leaving reformist political forces with little remaining capacity to mediate between the state and society.

At the same time, authorities intensified restrictions on personal freedoms, particularly women's clothing.

A July 2022 decision tightening enforcement of mandatory hijab rules, alongside an expanded presence of morality police patrols, increased pressure on women.

  • Iran's Raisi Orders Strict Enforcement Of Hijab Amid Crackdown

    Iran's Raisi Orders Strict Enforcement Of Hijab Amid Crackdown

The death of Mahsa Amini in September 2022 after her detention by morality police triggered another nationwide uprising.

Unlike the initial fuel-price protests of 2019, the 2022 movement brought together women, young people, middle-class Iranians, lower-income communities and protesters from different ethnic backgrounds.

Its demands centered on personal freedom, dignity and opposition to compulsory hijab, alongside rejection of the Islamic Republic's political structure.

A younger generation with limited attachment to official ideology or traditional political organizations occupied a central role.

The decentralized character of the demonstrations resembled November 2019, although tactics such as nighttime rooftop chanting also drew on earlier protest movements, including those of 2009.

Repression contains protests but leaves grievances unresolved

The November 2019 crackdown did not end nationwide protest in Iran.

Demonstrations over water shortages in Khuzestan in 2021, the 2022 uprising and the protests of January 2026 demonstrated the continued importance of the streets as a place of confrontation between citizens and the state.

Each wave involved different immediate grievances, but all unfolded against a backdrop of accumulated economic and political dissatisfaction.

Authorities repeatedly used arrests, violence and communications restrictions to contain demonstrations.

  • Tehran quelled street protests but economic troubles persist

    Tehran quelled street protests but economic troubles persist

Those measures increased the risks of participation and disrupted protesters' ability to organize, without addressing the conditions that had brought them into the streets.

The January 2026 protests followed the same broader trajectory.

Beginning with economic grievances, the demonstrations developed into a wider challenge to the political establishment and were met with the deadliest crackdown in decades.

The recurrence of protest also highlights the limits of interpreting the absence of demonstrations as public acceptance of existing conditions.

Participation depends not only on the depth of dissatisfaction but also on people's assessment of personal risk, their ability to communicate and their expectations about whether others will join them.

Lethal repression raises the perceived cost of taking to the streets, while internet shutdowns make it harder to coordinate gatherings or learn where protests are taking place.

Such measures can temporarily reduce demonstrations even when the underlying grievances remain.

Economic hardship continues to affect access to basic necessities, while restrictions on clothing and personal behavior sustain another source of dissatisfaction.

Authorities have also linked opposition to some of these restrictions with espionage or cooperation with foreign adversaries, extending security enforcement into everyday life.

That approach can increase the consequences of dissent while generating additional resentment over state interference.

The continuing economic strain, restrictions on personal freedoms and reliance on security measures have left the conditions for renewed protest largely intact.

From November 2019 to January 2026, the Islamic Republic has repeatedly demonstrated its capacity to suppress demonstrations, but not to prevent the emergence of new ones.

The central pattern remains unchanged: authorities can regain control of the streets through force, but suppressing a protest movement has not eliminated the grievances that brought it into being.