• العربية
  • فارسی
BrandBrand
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
  • Theme
  • Language
    • العربية
    • فارسی
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
All rights reserved for Volant Media UK Limited
volant media logo

Missile hits outskirts of Iran's Qeshm island shortly after Hormuz ship attack

Nov 20, 2026, 16:21 GMT+0

A missile struck the outskirts of Qeshm city at 6:50 p.m. local time (3:20 pm UTC) on Friday, the Revolutionary Guards-affiliated Tasnim news agency reported.

Twenty minutes earlier, a projectile had hit an oil tanker leaving the Strait of Hormuz near Oman, sparking a fire on board, according to UK Maritime Trade Operations.

Tasnim attributed the Qeshm strike to the United States and Israel but provided no details about damage or casualties.

Earlier Friday, the Guards-affiliated Fars news agency reported that residents had heard an explosion over Qeshm, with some witnesses describing a fiery flash in the sky.

Most Viewed

Tanker loads Iranian crude in Persian Gulf as Tehran weighs resuming exports
1

Tanker loads Iranian crude in Persian Gulf as Tehran weighs resuming exports

2
ANALYSIS

A tough winter for Iran's cement industry, a tougher one for steel

3

Houthi missile attack damages Riyadh’s tallest building

4

GTA 6 costs, slow internet frustrate Iranian gamers, fuel satire

5

Tehran seizes on NYT dam report to widen retaliation threats

Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner

Spotlight

  • Ideology or history? Analysts clash over the roots of Iran’s enmity with the US

    Ideology or history? Analysts clash over the roots of Iran’s enmity with the US

  • A test of power: Who will control Iran's state TV?
    INSIGHT

    A test of power: Who will control Iran's state TV?

  • GTA 6 costs, slow internet frustrate Iranian gamers, fuel satire

    GTA 6 costs, slow internet frustrate Iranian gamers, fuel satire

  • A tough winter for Iran's cement industry, a tougher one for steel
    ANALYSIS

    A tough winter for Iran's cement industry, a tougher one for steel

  • Tehran seizes on NYT dam report to widen retaliation threats

    Tehran seizes on NYT dam report to widen retaliation threats

  • How Iranians are turning grief into defiance
    OPINION

    How Iranians are turning grief into defiance

  • Iran could launch dirty-bomb attack, but risks make it unlikely
    ANALYSIS

    Iran could launch dirty-bomb attack, but risks make it unlikely

•
•
•

More Stories

Iran readies tankers to run US blockade, threatens Persian Gulf oil if fired on

Nov 20, 2026, 14:13 GMT+0
100%
Children play on the beach in Bandar Abbas, on the Strait of Hormuz, as tankers sit offshore, November 19, 2026.

Guards-linked media, lawmakers and Friday prayer leaders signaled this week that Iran is preparing to send tankers through the US naval blockade, and warned that any attack on them would bring strikes on oil facilities across the Persian Gulf.

“The blockade must be broken,” Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi told the ILNA news agency on Friday, when asked about reports that Iranian oil was being loaded for export. Iran would make every effort to export oil and to pursue negotiations, he said.

No Iranian official has confirmed a convoy. But the idea has moved in days from commentary by Revolutionary Guards-affiliated outlets to parliament and, on Friday, to prayer leaders in several cities, a path that decisions taken at the top in Tehran often follow before they are announced. Friday sermons are coordinated nationally by a council that answers to the supreme leader.

‘If a single bullet hits’

The campaign began on Wednesday, when the Guards-affiliated Fars news agency published a commentary urging Tehran to send a convoy of tankers through the blockade.

Iran should announce it officially, Fars said, and warn that any attack on the convoy would bring strikes on the region’s energy infrastructure, “especially UAE oil,” and on communications networks in Dubai.

On Thursday, the oil tracker TankerTrackers said Iran “appears to be preparing to ship out oil again.”

Its co-founder, Samir Madani, told Reuters that a tanker was taking on Iranian crude from another vessel in the Persian Gulf. If it cleared the blockade, it would be the first seaborne export of Iranian crude since mid-July. Al-Monitor reported that more than 14 Iranian tankers were gathered near Kharg Island, Iran’s main oil terminal, most with their tracking transponders switched off.

  • Iran war could cut global oil demand by over 4% by 2035 - IEA

    Iran war could cut global oil demand by over 4% by 2035 - IEA

  • Tanker loads Iranian crude in Persian Gulf as Tehran weighs resuming exports

    Tanker loads Iranian crude in Persian Gulf as Tehran weighs resuming exports

The Guards-affiliated Sabereen News, in a post labeled “unofficial,” said dozens of tankers were preparing to sail for China, and that Tehran had warned governments across the region it would go to war if the United States attacked them.

A Fars report said that any disruption to a tanker’s voyage would mean explosions at oil facilities in the UAE, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Kuwait, Oman and Bahrain. Fars illustrated its commentary with an image of Fereydun, the hero of the Persian epic the Shahnameh, on horseback in the sea, guarding Iranian ships.

Mostafa Najafi, described in Iranian media as an adviser to Mohsen Rezaei, secretary of the Supreme National Security Council, linked the plan to the top. The supreme leader had ordered an end to the state of “neither war nor peace,” he wrote, and “the military option is also on the agenda.” Tehran, he wrote, “no longer wants to watch the blockade and the threats.”

From parliament to the pulpit

Mohammad Bayat, a lawmaker on the presiding board of parliament’s Internal Affairs Committee, called on Friday for tankers to be readied and for “an ultimatum” to Washington and the region’s governments. Iran, he said, “must be the initiator” of practical steps to end the blockade.

In the northwestern city of Ardabil, prayer leader Hassan Ameli, a member of the Assembly of Experts, went furthest.

  • Iran's oil output plunges below pre-war domestic needs

    Iran's oil output plunges below pre-war domestic needs

  • Bessent says Iran economy will contract by more than 25%

    Bessent says Iran economy will contract by more than 25%

Officials had taken “a very important decision to break this siege,” he said, and tankers would soon set sail from Kharg for China.

“Our armed forces have warned the Americans that if a single shot is fired at them, all oil centers in the Persian Gulf countries will be Iran’s legitimate target,” he said.

In Tehran, Friday prayer leader Mohammad-Javad Haj-Aliakbari said the armed forces were ready “at sea, on land, in the air, everywhere,” with orders “to take unlimited, unrestricted action, at a time of our own choosing.” “If they want to test us, they can go ahead and test us,” he said.

In Khorramabad, in the west, Friday prayer leader Ahmadreza Shahrokhi urged the armed forces not to let the blockade continue, and said that if any attack came from the territory of the Persian Gulf states, the armed forces should target “the palaces” of their rulers.

In Yasuj, in the southwest, Nasir Hosseini said Iranians wanted the blockade broken “with the power of the nation and the armed forces” and spoke of nuclear deterrence. In Tabriz, Ahmad Motahari-Asl warned that Iran had “not yet closed” the Bab el-Mandeb strait at the mouth of the Red Sea.

The Guards’ commander, Ahmad Vahidi, said: “Today we have put part of a great battle behind us, and part of it lies ahead.”

Why now

The blockade has cut Iran off from its main source of foreign currency. Iran loaded about 2 million barrels of crude and condensate a day in March, Reuters reported, citing Kpler and Vortexa. By September, Kpler recorded no loadings at all, the first full month without any since the 1979 revolution. Production has fallen to about 1.8 million barrels a day, roughly half its prewar level.

Chinese refiners usually pay one to two months after delivery, so payments for Iran’s last cargoes could arrive by mid-December, Homayoun Falakshahi, Kpler’s head of crude oil analysis, has told Iran International. After that, Tehran stands to lose $3 billion to $6 billion a month.

  • Qatar turns to US LNG to cushion Iran war losses

    Qatar turns to US LNG to cushion Iran war losses

  • Once US blockaded Iran, China’s ‘Malaysian’ oil imports dried up

    Once US blockaded Iran, China’s ‘Malaysian’ oil imports dried up

Alihossein Ghazizadeh, an Iran International analyst, said Tehran had concluded that time was against it. Washington wants to keep the blockade in place until the state is weak enough to collapse, give in or face mass protest, he said, and fighting later would cost the United States less.

“If a war is going to happen in three months, it’s better that it happens today,” he said, describing Tehran’s thinking. Iran could provoke a clash, he said, but the decision to start a full-scale war would rest with the United States and Israel.

Washington tightens, and waits

The United States has moved the other way. On Wednesday, US Central Command widened the blockade to cover ship-to-ship transfers at sea. “Such ships may be stopped, boarded, diverted, captured, or directed to proceed to the Iranian port where the cargo originated,” it said, warning that ships failing to comply could face force. CENTCOM says it has redirected 150 merchant vessels and disabled five since June, and in September US forces struck several Iranian tankers near Kharg and Jask after the Guards fired missiles at a US warship.

President Donald Trump has signaled patience. He told Axios this week that he was in no rush to decide on Iran and would see what happened after the new year.

On Thursday he said he could end the war “immediately,” but that Saudi Arabia had asked him “to please just let it be the way it is now for a while, because [Iran is] disintegrating.”

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who runs the economic campaign, told CNBC this month that death threats against him from Iran’s leadership showed the pressure was working. Of the Guards, he said: “They’re like a dangerous cornered animal.”

Israel has pressed the other way. Mossad chief Roman Gofman was in Washington last week to urge a resumption of joint strikes, Axios and the Wall Street Journal reported.

If the tankers sail, Washington faces a choice it has so far avoided: let the blockade break, or fire on Iranian ships and test whether Tehran will carry out its threat against the Persian Gulf states.

Ex-boyfriend shoots woman dead at her birthday party in Iran

Nov 20, 2026, 12:36 GMT+0
100%
Sadaf Haghbin

A 23-year-old woman was shot dead at her own birthday party in Iran’s northern Gilan province by a former boyfriend after she refused to marry him, local media reported, days after a 16-year-old girl’s killing by her father set off a national outcry.

Sadaf Haghbin was killed in the early hours of Thursday in Choukam, in Khomam county near the road between Rasht and the Caspian port of Bandar Anzali.

A 29-year-old man walked into the party armed, locked the guests in a room and took Haghbin upstairs, local media in Gilan reported. The Kurdish rights group Hengaw, citing sources close to the family, said he beat her and pressed her to call her parents and say she agreed to marry him. When she refused, he shot her several times.

He shot her first in the heart, then in the face and finally in the head, the local outlet Hirkani reported, citing an informed source, before fleeing. He had a history of violence and abuse toward her, Hengaw said.

Khabaronline reported that her refusal of his proposal was the likely motive, though police have not confirmed it.

The police chief of Khomam county, Iman Jahandideh, said without naming Haghbin that a 29-year-old man had shot a 22-year-old woman with a hunting rifle over “personal disputes” and fled.

He was arrested a few hours later with the rifle, confessed and was handed to the judiciary, the police chief said.

Two killings in four days

Haghbin’s death came four days after Sogand Sayadi, a 16-year-old schoolgirl in the western city of Kermanshah, died after falling from the fifth floor of a building on November 15. Rights groups say her father threw her.

The day before, administrators at her girls’ high school had summoned her father over her relationship with a young man he opposed.

According to rights groups, he beat her in front of her classmates and school staff, after she had warned teachers that her father would kill her if they sent her home with him.

Kermanshah’s prosecutor opened an investigation, and her father was arrested on charges including assault and murder, along with the school principal, on charges of negligence. Iran’s main teachers’ union network condemned the school’s handling of the case.

A petition launched on Tuesday demanding a tough sentence for her father and a change to the law that shields him has gathered more than 220,000 signatures.

A law that protects fathers

Under Article 301 of Iran’s Islamic Penal Code, a father or paternal grandfather who kills his child cannot face qisas, or retribution in kind, the punishment for most murders. He faces at most a prison term, and in practice often a short one.

The rule has been at the center of Iran’s most notorious cases. In May 2020, 14-year-old Romina Ashrafi was beheaded with a sickle by her father in Talesh, also in Gilan province, after she ran away with a man he opposed.

He was sentenced to nine years. In February 2022, 17-year-old Mona Heydari was beheaded by her husband in Ahvaz, in the southwest, who walked through the streets with her head. Each case set off outrage online and calls for reform that were never met.

A bill to protect women from violence has been stuck for about 16 years between the government, parliament and other state bodies and has still not become law.

At least 84 women and girls

At least 84 women and girls were killed in Iran between March 21 and October 13, 12 of them under 18, the Emtedad news site reported on Monday, citing cases reported in the media. Eight of the underage victims were killed by fathers, brothers or other blood relatives.

  • Killing of Iranian schoolgirl sparks calls for legal reform

    Killing of Iranian schoolgirl sparks calls for legal reform

  • Iranian girl's suspected honor killing raises questions over school's role

    Iranian girl's suspected honor killing raises questions over school's role

In August, another 16-year-old in Kermanshah, Hana Rakan, was shot in the head by her father while she slept, Hengaw reported.

The Shargh newspaper reported on Thursday that 125 women and children had died from domestic violence between late March and November. Both counts rely on reported cases and are likely to understate the real number.

After Haghbin’s death, users on social media posted the names of women and girls killed by family members or partners in recent weeks.

Iran sentences taekwondo champion to death over January protests

Nov 20, 2026, 11:37 GMT+0
100%

Iran has sentenced Pouya Fakhrabadi, a 25-year-old national taekwondo champion, to death over a fire during January’s protests in the central city of Yazd, and a source told Iran International he was tortured into confessing.

Judge Mohammad Bemani, who heads Branch 2 of Yazd’s Revolutionary Court, issued the sentence in a joint case known as the “Yazd telecommunications” case, according to information received by Iran International and the rights group HRANA.

Three other men in the case, Mehdi Rajabi, Mohammad Kargar and Mohini Makki, were each sentenced to 20 years, to be served in internal exile in the prison of Zahedan, in Sistan and Baluchestan province, more than 800 kilometers away.

  • The faceless judge who sentenced 11 Iranian protesters to death in 2026

    The faceless judge who sentenced 11 Iranian protesters to death in 2026

The charge announced was “taking part in setting fire to public property.” The details of the accusations against the men are not known, and it is not clear whether Fakhrabadi has appealed.

The case stems from protests on January 8 and 9, the days of the January massacre, when Imam Hossein Square in Yazd was one of the city’s main protest sites. The telecommunications building on the square and other government offices nearby, including one belonging to the Imam Khomeini Relief Committee, a state welfare foundation, caught fire.

100%
Pouya Fakhrabadi

‘They broke his head with a rifle butt’

Fakhrabadi, who holds a master’s degree in physical education, was arrested at his home in Yazd on February 20, a source familiar with the case told Iran International. Security agents broke his head with a rifle butt during the raid, leaving a wound that needed 20 stitches, the source said.

In solitary confinement he was severely beaten and tortured and lost about 30 kilograms, the source said. Agents forced him to confess by threatening to kill members of his family and to sexually abuse them. He was denied a lawyer throughout the case.

  • Abdanan protests draw solidarity and fears of renewed crackdown

    Abdanan protests draw solidarity and fears of renewed crackdown

His sister, who saw the violence during his arrest, suffered severe panic attacks and could barely speak for months afterward, the source said.

Fakhrabadi is a champion in hanmadang, the taekwondo discipline of creative and power breaking. He won gold at the international Kukkiwon Cup, organized by the sport’s world headquarters in South Korea, and has won a national title, setting a new record.

The Yazd detainees

Of 28 people from the January protests held in Yazd prison, 15 have been sentenced to between three and 21 years, and 13 are still awaiting a verdict, HRANA reported on Tuesday.

In the months since the protests, Iran’s judiciary has handed down death sentences, prison terms, floggings and asset confiscations to many of those detained and to other political prisoners.

On Wednesday, the UN General Assembly’s human rights committee adopted a draft resolution condemning the crackdown on the January protests and calling for a halt to all executions, with a view to abolishing the death penalty.

A lawyer facing a wartime charge

In Isfahan, prosecutors have extended the detention of human rights lawyer Amirsalar Davoudi by 30 days and added a new charge, his lawyer, Mehdi Karimi Farsi, told the Emtedad news site.

  • Iranian rights lawyer suffered heart attack in detention, rights group says

    Iranian rights lawyer suffered heart attack in detention, rights group says

  • UN experts warn Iran's crackdown on lawyers imperils fair trials

    UN experts warn Iran's crackdown on lawyers imperils fair trials

Davoudi, who was sentenced in 2019 to 30 years in prison and 111 lashes over his work defending political prisoners, was arrested again on October 11. He already faced charges of “spreading falsehoods online,” “propaganda against the system” and “inciting people to war and killing each other to disrupt national security.” He now also faces “producing and spreading false news against national security in wartime.”

Moein Khazaeli, a lawyer, wrote on X that prosecutors brought the new charge under Article 4 of a law toughening penalties for espionage, passed after the June 2025 war. It carries 10 to 15 years in prison, he said, or death if the court treats it as “corruption on earth.” He said the law was being used to stop lawyers defending their clients.

Part of the case against Davoudi stems from a recording he posted on Instagram on October 4 of a wedding ceremony conducted by phone between two of his imprisoned clients, Mahshad Keshani and Alireza Sepahi Badjani. Sepahi Badjani was executed the next day.

Davoudi suffered a heart attack in solitary confinement on November 8 and was taken to Isfahan’s Al-Zahra hospital, Iran Human Rights reported. The next morning, he was taken to court to be charged. He has had no contact with his family since his arrest, his lawyer said, despite a court order on November 15 allowing calls.

UN human rights experts said on November 9 that Davoudi’s arrest was part of a campaign of pressure on independent lawyers, at least 135 of whom faced judicial or security action in Iran between September 2025 and September 2026.

Iraq begins taking back town held for a decade by Iran’s strongest militia ally

Nov 20, 2026, 10:24 GMT+0
100%
Members of the Iraqi police take part in a security deployment on the outskirts of Jurf al-Sakhar, Babil province, Iraq, November 20, 2026.

Iraqi forces began deploying on Friday in Jurf al-Sakhar, a town south of Baghdad held for more than a decade by Iran’s most powerful militia ally in Iraq, under a deal brokered by Shiite leaders days after the head of Iran’s Quds Force arrived in Baghdad.

A convoy flying Iraqi flags drove toward Jurf al-Sakhar on Friday, and hundreds of soldiers took up positions on the outskirts.

The yellow flags of Kataib Hezbollah were still flying farther inside the town, and none of the group’s fighters were visible. A security headquarters is due to open on Saturday to oversee the handover, with a unit assigned to protect energy facilities.

Under the deal, Kataib Hezbollah fighters are to withdraw to other parts of Iraq, Reuters reported, citing security officials. Al Arabiya, citing sources, said the withdrawal would be phased over a month. A joint command of the army, federal police, energy police and units of the Popular Mobilization Forces is taking over the town.

The standoff began on Monday, when Prime Minister Ali al-Zaidi ordered troops to prepare to enter Jurf al-Sakhar after an investigation accused Kataib Hezbollah of running a network that siphoned off hundreds of millions of dollars’ worth of state oil through tampered pipelines.

Nine senior security and oil officials were dismissed, and arrests linked to the case raised fears of an armed confrontation. The group denies the accusations and had warned it would resist any attempt to enter the town.

The same day, Esmail Qaani, commander of the Revolutionary Guards’ Quds Force, which runs Iran’s network of allied armed groups abroad, arrived in Baghdad to help defuse the crisis, Iraqi Shiite political sources told Reuters. Kataib Hezbollah said its leader, Abu Hussein al-Hamidawi, met Qaani and Hadi al-Amiri, head of the Iran-backed Badr Organization, in the talks that led to the deal.

A town nobody could enter

Jurf al-Sakhar, a Sunni farming town on the Euphrates about 50 kilometers south of Baghdad, was retaken from Islamic State in 2014 by the army and Shiite militias, Kataib Hezbollah among them. Its residents were never allowed back. More than 100,000 people from the town and surrounding villages remain displaced, Shafaq News reported, and even government officials have rarely been let in.

  • Iraq’s move on militia stronghold may do little to curb Iran’s influence

    Iraq’s move on militia stronghold may do little to curb Iran’s influence

  • Baghdad readies for ‘zero hour’ at militia stronghold after IRGC Qaani visits Iraq

    Baghdad readies for ‘zero hour’ at militia stronghold after IRGC Qaani visits Iraq

  • Iraq reaches deal with Iran-backed militia over Baghdad stronghold

    Iraq reaches deal with Iran-backed militia over Baghdad stronghold

The town sits near the roads linking Baghdad with Karbala and Anbar province, and has served as a financial hub for evading sanctions on Iran, said Omar Mohammed, an Iraqi historian known for documenting life under Islamic State as Mosul Eye. He called the move “a theatrical show.”

“I think maybe the Iranian-backed militias will allow them some cosmetic gains, but there’s no way that Iran is going to allow its footprint in Iraq to disappear,” David Patrikarakos, a journalist and author of a book on Iran’s nuclear program, told Iran International earlier this week.

Iran’s strongest arm in Iraq

Kataib Hezbollah was founded after the 2003 US-led invasion of Iraq by Abu Mahdi al-Muhandis, who was killed alongside Quds Force commander Qassem Soleimani in a US drone strike at Baghdad airport in January 2020. Washington designated it a terrorist organization in 2009 and blamed it for a January 2024 drone attack that killed three US soldiers at a base in Jordan.

It is among the most influential members of the Islamic Resistance in Iraq, an umbrella of Iran-backed factions that has claimed more than 150 attacks on US forces since the Gaza war began in 2023, and more recently on US troops in the Persian Gulf states.

The militias report directly to Iran’s Revolutionary Guards. Their arsenals include anti-tank guided missiles, precision-guided rockets, armed drones and some short-range ballistic and cruise missiles, according to Iraqi security officials.

Kataib Hezbollah has thousands of fighters and no announced leadership structure. It forms several battalions of the Popular Mobilization Forces, an umbrella of mostly Shiite armed factions set up in 2014 to fight Islamic State and later made an official state force.

Its fighters draw state salaries, and some of its members designated as terrorists by the United States hold senior posts in the PMF. It also has a political party, Huquq, with five lawmakers, and business interests in construction, housing, trade and currency exchange, according to an Iraqi official report. The group denies these.

Since the United States and Israel went to war with Iran on February 28, Iraqi militias have struck US troops and facilities in Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. President Donald Trump has pressed Zaidi to disarm them, and the factions have refused to hand over their weapons.

100%
Members of the Iraqi police take part in a security deployment on the outskirts of Jurf al-Sakhar, Babil province, Iraq, November 20, 2026.

A risky test for Baghdad

Moving against the militias carries a price. In November 2021, after then-Prime Minister Mustafa al-Kadhimi ordered a crackdown, his Baghdad home was hit by an armed drone in what officials called an assassination attempt.

In August, Iraqi special forces arrested the intelligence chief of another Iran-aligned faction, Harakat al-Nujaba, over drone attacks on US targets. He was released 48 hours later after threats of retaliation and the intervention of senior Shiite politicians.

Iraq is also tied to Iran in ways that a single town cannot change. It imports Iranian gas and electricity, and the militias’ access to dollars and to trade has made Iraq one of Iran’s main routes around sanctions. The US Treasury barred 14 Iraqi banks from dollar transactions in 2023 over suspected links to Iran, and in 2025 it sanctioned a businessman accused of smuggling Iranian oil disguised as Iraqi crude.

John Craig, a former US ambassador, called Baghdad’s move “about 10 years overdue.” Whether Zaidi can do more, he said, would show how serious he is.

Ideology or history? Analysts clash over the roots of Iran’s enmity with the US

Nov 20, 2026, 09:35 GMT+0
•
Maryam Sinaiee
100%
A screenshot from the debate between Shahram Ettefagh and Jafar Shiralinia, published by Azad on November 18, 2026.

Is Iran’s four-decade confrontation with the United States a product of the Islamic Republic’s ideology, or of an older conflict over Iran’s place in the world? Two Iranian analysts clashed over the question in a debate published online on Wednesday.

Political researcher Shahram Ettefagh, whose views are close to liberalism and free-market economics, argued that the hostility is rooted in the ideology of the state founded after the 1979 revolution.

Historian Jafar Shiralinia, who studies Iran’s contemporary history, said it reflects a longer struggle between Iran and Western powers that began well before 1979. The prerecorded debate was released on the YouTube channel of Azad, a popular online political debate and talk show.

‘A system of beliefs’

Anti-Americanism became inseparable from the Islamic Republic’s political ideology after the revolution, Ettefagh said, first shaped by leftist ideas and then built into the state’s founding paradigm.

He pointed to the attacks on the United States, Israel and Arab governments in the revolution’s first months, the creation of an annual Quds Day for Jerusalem, calls for people across the region to rise against their rulers, and the seizure of the US Embassy in Tehran, where diplomats were held hostage for 444 days.

That framework would block any real change in relations with the West, he said, even if the two sides reached a deal to end the current war.

“Any reflection on the present moment in Iran, or on Iran’s future, is undoubtedly dependent on this paradigm, this system of beliefs and ideas that still governs the Islamic Republic,” he said.

The ideology was also an obstacle to Iran’s development, Ettefagh said. Iran had worked with the West at various points in its history, and its troubles with Western countries should not be blamed on a permanent hostility toward Iran.

‘An issue involving Iran, not the Iranian government’

Shiralinia rejected the idea that the conflict should be read mainly through the events of 1979. “I see this as an issue involving Iran, not the Iranian government,” he said.

Iran’s efforts to industrialize, build national power and develop strategic technologies had long met resistance from major powers, including the United States, he said, rooted in a strategic and civilizational outlook toward non-Western societies rather than in disagreement with any one government’s policies.

He cited moments when Tehran had sought to ease tensions and relations soured anyway: Iran’s cooperation with the United States in Afghanistan after the September 11 attacks, which was followed months later by President George W. Bush naming Iran part of an “axis of evil,” and the outreach of President Mohammad Khatami’s government.

Iran’s own mistakes, including the embassy seizure, should not be defended, Shiralinia said, but they had to be weighed alongside Washington’s military, political and economic policies, which he said many analyses overlook.

The 1953 coup

The sharpest disagreement was over 1953, when Prime Minister Mohammad Mossadegh, who had nationalized Iran’s oil industry, was removed from power.

Shiralinia called the US-backed coup a turning point that turned clerics, leftists and nationalists alike against Washington. “Before the coup, public opinion and even intellectuals did not view America as negatively as they did afterward,” he said.

Ettefagh rejected that account. “I do not accept the idea that America came and carried out a coup in Iran,” he said.

“The coup that took place was Mossadegh’s coup against the Shah, and the Shah, as the higher authority, had the right under the constitutional monarchy to dismiss him.”

The Shah did issue a decree dismissing Mossadegh in August 1953. The operation to remove him was organized by American and British intelligence, a role the CIA acknowledged in documents declassified in 2013.

The debate left the two men divided on whether the confrontation would outlast the Islamic Republic. For Ettefagh, it is the product of the state’s ideological choices. For Shiralinia, it is a conflict involving Iran as a country, one that could survive a change of government.