• العربية
  • فارسی
BrandBrand
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
  • Theme
  • Language
    • العربية
    • فارسی
  • Iran Insight
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Analysis
  • Special Report
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Live TV
All rights reserved for Volant Media UK Limited
volant media logo
OPINION

Sanctions snapback on Iran is about compliance, not politics

Shahram Kholdi
Shahram Kholdi

International Security and Law Analyst

Aug 4, 2025, 16:11 GMT+1Updated: 05:37 GMT+0
A meeting of the United Nations Security Council
A meeting of the United Nations Security Council

A resilient anti-sanctions consensus dominated major Western policy circles and media narratives for a decade, but this stance risks undermining international law by normalizing Iran’s sustained nuclear defiance.

Prominent foreign policy journals, think tanks and legacy media outlets have consistently portrayed the UN sanctions "snapback" mechanism under UNSCR 2231 not as a legal obligation but as a geopolitical hazard.

Reimposing sanctions, they argue, would empower Iranian hardliners, obstruct humanitarian aid and alienate allies. Though presented as cautious and pragmatic, such positions align with Tehran’s longstanding arguments.

This consensus persists despite mounting evidence of Iran’s sustained non-compliance.

In March 2025, US President Donald Trump issued a 60-day ultimatum demanding Iran reduce enrichment and allow expanded IAEA access. Tehran swiftly rejected the demand.

On the 61st day, Israel struck Iranian nuclear sites, capped off by deeper US strikes on underground enrichment facilities on June 22. A ceasefire took effect on June 24, but the crisis persisted.

100%
Table 1 - Chronology of events March-July 2025

Recent escalation, strategic defiance

The IAEA’s resolution of June 12, 2025, confirmed that undeclared nuclear material remained unaccounted for and that the Agency could no longer verify the peaceful nature of Iran’s nuclear program.

On July 4–5, 2025, Iran expelled all inspectors and terminated monitoring protocols, eliminating the last vestige of international oversight.

These actions—alongside continued enrichment to 60%—represent clear violations of Articles II and III of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) which bar non-nuclear-weapon states from acquiring certain nuclear technologies and mandate IAEA safeguards.

Although Article IV affirms a right to peaceful nuclear energy, that right is strictly conditional upon compliance with Articles II and III. In the words of former IAEA deputy chief Pierre Goldschmidt, "enrichment is not an unconditional entitlement."

These violations explicitly trigger the condition of "significant non-performance" under UNSCR 2231, legally mandating sanctions snapback."

100%
Table 2 - UN sanctions regimes

Binding legal obligations

The snapback mechanism embedded in UNSCR 2231 reflects the principle that enforcement must not be held hostage to political convenience.

Iran’s material breaches—expelling inspectors, concealing enriched uranium, continuing high-level enrichment, and refusing to account for undeclared material—trigger conditions for significant non-performance.

UNSCR 2231 operates under Chapter VII of the UN Charter. Articles 39–42 empower the Security Council to determine threats and impose binding measures.

Article 25 obligates all Member States to “accept and carry out” such decisions, while Article 103 ensures Charter obligations supersede conflicting treaties—including the JCPOA.

No expiry date

The International Court of Justice, in its 1971 Namibia Advisory Opinion, affirmed that resolutions under Chapter VII bind all Member States. Once reinstated, sanctions remain legally binding until explicitly lifted by another resolution of equal authority.

International law broadly supports this, as noted by scholars Sue Eckert and Haroun Rahimi. Sanctions do not expire through diplomacy or political shifts. They remain binding.

The Istanbul summit on July 25, 2025, convened Iran and the E3 (UK, France, Germany) amid intense diplomatic pressure but produced no breakthrough.

Iran had already expelled inspectors and resumed 60% enrichment. Uranium removed before the June strikes remains unaccounted for.

The July 22 Qaem-100 satellite launch, despite civilian framing, clearly signals ongoing dual-use missile capabilities. On July 21, Araghchi publicly asserted Iran would proceed regardless of international pressure. The pattern is unmistakable: deliberate defiance.

Abdication not caution

Upholding UNSCR 2231 through snapback is not an expedient—it is a legal obligation. When enforcement mechanisms are neglected, the architecture of deterrence collapses. Delay becomes paralysis, and paralysis risks open conflict.

As Winston Churchill warned amid interwar failures of collective security: "The malice of the wicked was reinforced by the weakness of the virtuous."

Deferring action under UNSCR 2231 amounts not to caution but to abdication.

The E3 now stands at a historical precipice. It can uphold the very enforcement mechanism it established in 2015 or to let it lapse—and with it, allow binding Security Council resolutions to fade into irrelevance.

Triggering snapback means defending the Charter and forestalling further conflict in an already volatile region.

Most Viewed

Iran’s dams may have been built to support missile bases - NYT
1

Iran’s dams may have been built to support missile bases - NYT

2

US Army seeks 17 bunkers in Israel, Saudi, Lebanon amid Iran threats - report

3

UK PM warns Iran against attacks on journalists and military bases

4

Senior Guards commander admits deep Israeli intelligence infiltration

5

Iran’s daily hardships find a voice in IRGC-linked media

Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner

Spotlight

  • Iran's wartime rallies turn against officials, fuel political feuds

    Iran's wartime rallies turn against officials, fuel political feuds

  • How Thai clerics in Iran were recruited to attack Israeli embassy in Bangkok
    EXCLUSIVE

    How Thai clerics in Iran were recruited to attack Israeli embassy in Bangkok

  • Mapping aircraft losses from US-Israeli strikes on Tehran airport
    SPECIAL REPORT

    Mapping aircraft losses from US-Israeli strikes on Tehran airport

  • Iraq’s move on militia stronghold may do little to curb Iran’s influence
    ANALYSIS

    Iraq’s move on militia stronghold may do little to curb Iran’s influence

  • 'Our turn to play': Iran hardliners call for breaking US blockade

    'Our turn to play': Iran hardliners call for breaking US blockade

  • Head full of pellets: protester recalls ordeal on Iran holiday island
    EXCLUSIVE

    Head full of pellets: protester recalls ordeal on Iran holiday island

  • Israeli opposition to Islamic Republic transcends party lines
    ONE-ON-ONE

    Israeli opposition to Islamic Republic transcends party lines